American Idol: only three more weeks of this!

So yeah, I forgot to tape the show. Here are my rankings, based on some video clips and mp3s.

1) Archuleta "America." Hate the song choice, love how he sang it.
2) Syesha "Thank the Lord for the Night Time." So Broadway it hurts.
3) Castro 'Forever in Blue Jeans." Perfect song for him.
4) Brooke "I Am...I Said." Very Brooke. I'm so glad she had one good performance.
5) Syesha "Hello Again." She had a great night tonight.
6) Archuleta "Sweet Caroline." Penalized because it's the Red Sox song.
7) Cook "All I Really Need is You." Parts of it were good, I guess.
8) Cook "I'm Alive." Most of this was not good.
9) Castro "September Morn." More like September Bore.
10) Brooke "I'm a Believer." Ouch. Her voice is definitely not strong enough for this song.

Overall:
1) Syesha
2) Archuleta

(Monstrous Gap)

3) Castro
4) Cook
5)Brooke

Syesha still has no fanbase, but Brooke has been struggling for awhile now. However, it might be time for a shock! bottom three placement, so keep an eye out for one of the David to flirt with disaster and rejuvenate their fanbase before their inevitable showdown in the finals.

Bottom Two: Brooke, Syesha
Going home: Brooke